Would it be possible to roughen up the surface of the 3D-printed material instead (sanding, application of a layer of glue/seamgrip/other stuff that gives a slightly tacky surface)? I'm now thinking of the poly band on my Majacraft, too... I hope you find a satisfactory solution at some point, even if it is too late for the actual test.
When I restored my Canadian Production Wheel, I accidentally got too much Danish oil in the groove of the whorl. Hours later, after trying and failing to make the band stop slipping and get some takeup, DH suggested folding some coarse sand paper in half and sanding out the groove.
Duh. Why didn't I think of that?? It's a very effective fix - you should try that on your 3D whorl grooves before giving up. It might just work as well for you as it did for me!
Thank you for all your comments! Isis, I used the material that was in the printer - the very normal, common plastic stuff that can be smoothed out with acetone fumes. (I didn't smooth it, obviously.)
Wanderingskopos and tinfoilhat, I might try both methods, roughing up and making sticky. I am also considering getting a poly band, though the thinnest I can find is 2 mm in diameter, and I'm not convinced this is thin enough. I'll try that, probably, though.
By accepting you will be accessing a service provided by a third-party external to https://www.pallia.net/